To be honest, with the MCU standing at 21 films (22 as soon as Avengers Endgame drops), I find it too challenging to rate all of the movies together so I've stopped trying. In a way I really don't think that its fair to try and rate all of the MCU films together. Why? So much has been developed and perfected that comparing The Avengers to Aveneger Infinity War is simply not a fair comparison. Another example is THOR compared to THOR RAGNORAK.
This is the first part to a three part series. We start with MCU's Phase 1 (a 6 part series) rated from Low to High... and riddled with spoilers!
![]() |
| Phase 1 started with Iron Man followed by The Incredible Hulk, Iron Man 2, Thor, Captain America: The First Avenger and concluding with The Avengers. |
6. THOR
Not only is THOR a lackluster origin story, it doesn't stand-up to the rewatch factor making its turn in the Avengers Infinity Saga Marathon a little painful. Overall, THOR earns a well deserved lackluster 6.5 Stars.
The Good
- Loki's casting was PERFECT!
- Loki's character written PERFECTLY!
- Set and costume designs were great
- Comic relief worked really well to keep the tone light
- Chris Hemsworth makes a perfect Thor
- We got MORE SHIELD and Agent Coulson
- Loki may have stole the show
- Thor almost shared TOO much of the story with Loki and Jane Foster feeling like a supporting character
- Thor came across as unlikable
- Thor's trials and tribulations did not feel harsh enough to warrant his character growth
5. The Incredible Hulk
I remember going to the theater to see Incredible Hulk. This was back before the 7pm showings the day before the global release. We were there before midnight and I was really excited about this film. I remember the theater passing around an XBOX 360 controller as people were taking turns playing the new HULK game as we waited for the movie to start. Ahhh... good times.
After Ang Lee's HULK in the early 2000's failed to deliver I'd given up hope on a good HULK movie. My hope was restored at the end of Iron Man when we learned that Nick Fury was working on a special project called The Avengers Initiative. This was really all I needed in order to be excited about The Incredible Hulk. The Trailers looked great. Ed Norton was an amazing actor and I thought he would do a great job at Bruce Banner. I couldn't wait.... and at the time the Incredible Hulk delivered a gamma packed punch. I was actually taken aback by the level of anger, rage and aggression they managed to capture on screen. The final fight between Hulk and Abomination was almost too much for my 6 year old stepson. For the first time I felt like they got HULK right on the big screen.
Unfortunately, retrospect kicks in and kinda brings down the film. Based on the issues between the director, the studio and Ed Norton there is a bit of a blemish on the memory of the Incredible Hulk. Ed Norton was replaced as Bruce Banner by Mark Ruffalo and Joss Whedon changed the visual appearance of the Hulk for The Avengers. These changes honestly leaves The Incredible Hulk feeling like the unwanted step-child of the entire MCU Infinity Saga.
More than anything, the rewatch factor of The Incredible Hulk has continued to decrease. Maybe more recent films like Thor Ragnarok or Avenger Infinity War made the serious tones of The Incredible Hulk too heavy. Overall, The Incredible Hulk earns a rating or 7 Stars.
The Good
- We got to see Hulk throw down with Abomination and not hold back
- Hulk fighting a storm to protect Betty was great
- Ed Norton is a fantasic actor
- The Campus scene was the high point of the film
- Seeing Emil Blonsky move like Captain America gave me hope for the Captain America movie
- The way Betty Ross looks at Bruce Banner is the dream
- Despite Ed Norton's performance, the film felt too heavy and serious making any comic relief seem odd and forced
- The changs of Norton to Ruffalo along with the bad press and visual character design change hurt the film long term
- dated graphics look cartoony; Hulk's face looks like the zombies from "Last Man on Earth"
By all rights, Iron Man 2 is a great sequel that feels like a continuation of the first Iron Man. Films like Sam Rami's Spider-Man/Spider-Man 2 and Christopher Nolan's Batman Begins/The Dark Knight Rises set an expectation that a sequel should be BIGGER and BETTER than its predecessor. Iron Man 2 proves that is not necessary.
Iron Man 2 does a great job of continuing to build upon the Iron Man and MCU universe. Not only do we get the most exposure to Nick Fury, we get to meet Black Widow. We also get a chance to learn more about Tony's father Howard Stark. We get WarMachine including a hint at just how bad Tony can be if his drinking and partying were to go unchecked or if the Iron Man tech were to fall into the wrong hands. We also got to see a few new Iron Man armors. The only issue I have with Iron Man 2 is the main villain was too easy to beat. It took no effort to beat the drones or Ivan Vanko.
With Iron Man 2 feeling like a continuation of Iron Man the rewatch factor has remained solid over the past 8-9 years. The film stands strong as a sequel and plays an important part in the budding relationship between Tony and Pepper. Avenger Endgame may play an important role proving that the importance of Iron Man 2 is much greater than initially realized. If it is proven that Tony synthesized the power of the Tesseract (Reality Stone) it may a key role in defeating Thanos.
Overall, I give Iron Man 2 a rather generous 7.5 Stars.
The Good
- Makes a fantastic sequel
- Introduces the concept of continued evolution and advancement of Iron Man tech
- We got War Machine
- We got more of the chemistry between Tony and Pepper
- May have setup a plot point for Avengers Endgame as Tony may have synthesized the power of the Tesseract (Reality Stone)
- The main villains was beaten easily
- Favreau played it safe and did not try to raise the bar
- Stark seems a bit overly careless at times
- Generic plot point of the main character not openly sharing his health issues keeping everyone but the viewer in the dark
SOME people may see Iron Man as #3 overall for Phase 1 and be like, "What the damn hell?!" Hear me out...
Iron Man was fantastic... and it still is. For me the #1 and #2 spots are neck-and-neck with #3 not too far behind. Robert Downey JR is amazing as Tony Stark. As I stated above, he is insanely charasmatic... and really finds a way to be a complete jerk yet still be super lika--LOVABLE. But all love is not due to RDJR's performance. Much praise to Jon Favreau for the world he created and story he told. He put Tony through HELL in that first film and it made his character growth entirely believable. Again, this is where Thor failed.
As far as rewatch factor, Iron Man is still a fun watch after 11 years, even with the dated graphics. The only thing holding it back from a higher rating is the ending. The film drops off a bit after he sends the Mark 3 into production. It was almost too easy of a story and ultimately IronMonger came across as a bit cheesy and cliche.
End of the day, Iron Man earns a WELL deserved 8 Stars.
The Good
- Robert Downey JR is the PERFECT Tony Stark
- One of the best origin stories in the MCU
- The Iron Man armor is amazing
- Made me actually like Iron Man AND Tony Stark
- Intorduction of SHIELD and Agent Coulson
- Extra Points for taking POST CREDIT scenes to the next level FOREVER!!!
- Movie kinda "Jumps the Shark" after the Mark 3 armor is built
- Iron Monger was cheesy and being a killer was a stretch
2. Captain America: The First Avenger
I know some of you may think I'm crazy, BUT I absolutely LOVE Cap's first solo film. It is one of the first Phase 1 films to connect to the Infinity Saga with the introduction of the Tesseract. Although at the time we did not know it contained the reality stone.
I can't think of a better story than what we got.
I've rewatched Captain America: The First Avenger more than any other MCU film and I honestly enjoy it every single time as much as I did the first time. As a result, Captain America earns a well deserved 8.5 Stars.
I can't think of a better story than what we got.
I've rewatched Captain America: The First Avenger more than any other MCU film and I honestly enjoy it every single time as much as I did the first time. As a result, Captain America earns a well deserved 8.5 Stars.
The Good
- Chris Evans is the PERFECT Captain America
- Hugo Weaving is the PERFECT Red Skull
- I loved how we got to see Cap in his classic costume
- The 2nd best origin story in the MCU (2nd to Iron Man)
- The film finishes as strong as it started
- Establish Steve Roger's the man and soldier before Captain America the hero
- Is there really ANYTHING bad about the first Captain America movie? (The answer is no... no there isnt)
1. The Avengers
It only took 6 MCU films to get to the first Avengers movie but I'd waited 30 years (way back in 2012) to get there. Joss Whedon did a fantastic job of telling such an amazing adventure with this first installment. He brought together the Avengers in a story that seemed impossible yet paid homage and respect to the original Avengers comic. This reason alone is why The Avengers earns the #1 spot out of the MCU Phase 1.
One of my favorite moments was when Thor arrives to take Loki back to Asgard. The fight that followed was truly impressive but the highlight of this scene was just before Iron Man attacks Thor. Thor pleading with Loki to return to home to Asgard was powerful. You could tell Loki wanted to abandon his plan and return home but he was in major trouble. We got to fully understand his fear in Avengers Infinity War as his failures brought him face-to-face with Thanos.
As I wait for the premier of the 22nd MCU film with Avengers Endgame, now 45 hours away, it's interesting to think how groundbreaking and amazing The Avengers was and what it meant to all of us. Seeing the Avengers stand side-by-side as the camera panned around them, I may have felt a bit emotional. I'm not ashamed. The first time was during my first of 6 theatrical viewings Sam Raimi's Spider-Man when we saw a full costumed Spider-Man web-slinging for the first time. Honestly, I wish my brother could have experienced this with me. In 2 days we get our 4th Avengers but I still love what Marvel achieved and gave us with The Avengers. Without question, The Avengers earns 8.5 Stars.
One of my favorite moments was when Thor arrives to take Loki back to Asgard. The fight that followed was truly impressive but the highlight of this scene was just before Iron Man attacks Thor. Thor pleading with Loki to return to home to Asgard was powerful. You could tell Loki wanted to abandon his plan and return home but he was in major trouble. We got to fully understand his fear in Avengers Infinity War as his failures brought him face-to-face with Thanos.
As I wait for the premier of the 22nd MCU film with Avengers Endgame, now 45 hours away, it's interesting to think how groundbreaking and amazing The Avengers was and what it meant to all of us. Seeing the Avengers stand side-by-side as the camera panned around them, I may have felt a bit emotional. I'm not ashamed. The first time was during my first of 6 theatrical viewings Sam Raimi's Spider-Man when we saw a full costumed Spider-Man web-slinging for the first time. Honestly, I wish my brother could have experienced this with me. In 2 days we get our 4th Avengers but I still love what Marvel achieved and gave us with The Avengers. Without question, The Avengers earns 8.5 Stars.
The Good
The Bad
- The Hulk and Thor fight was spectacular
- We finally saw a truly angry Hulk that wanted to smash and destroy everything
- I liked that we had more than just heroes with solo films on the team (Black Widow and Hawkeye)
- We finally got to see the full extent of SHIELD and the Helicarrier
- Hulk's line and all that lead up to it, "Puny God"
- The introduction of Thanos
- Loki was truly a sinister villain
The Bad
- The defeat of the Chiturai was too easy
- Loki's scepter was said to be controlled by the Tesseract when in reality it contained the Mind Stone (we learn this later in Avengers Age of Ultron)
- Whedon's Captain America was NOT the leader he should have been
- Captain America's costume was the worst
- The awkward thought of what would have Hulk done to Black Widow if Thor had not intervened
- Captain America's proclamation that "there is only one God and he doesn't dress like that" seemed a bit unnecessary (I get it... Cap's old old school but I don't see Cap openly dismissing the existence of any religious beliefs)
6. Thor - 6.5 Stars
5. The Incredible Hulk - 7 Stars
4. Iron Man 2 - 7.5 Stars
3. Iron Man - 8 Stars
2. Captain America: The First Avenger - 8.5 Stars
1. The Avengers - 8.5 Stars











